Editorial: A clear win

Editorial: A clear win


Members of the Davenport Civil Rights Commission hold a special meeting in the City Council Chambers, presided over by Mayor Mike Matson, Thursday, Feb. 6, 2020, in Davenport.

Finally, a dose of sanity in the Davenport Civil Rights Commission fiasco.

Scott County District Judge Henry Latham last week ordered that four former members of the commission – Susan Greenwalt, Nicole Bribriesco-Ledger, Clyde Mayfield and Helen Roberson – stop acting like they still hold office.

The ruling was a temporary injunction, but the judge made it pretty clear the city will probably win the argument in the underlying case over who rightfully sits on the commission. In February, the city filed a petition for a declaratory judgment on the matter.

The court's decision should come as no surprise to anybody who’s paid attention to this matter. The basic facts are these: A set of commissioners saw their terms expire. Former Mayor Frank Klipsch legally appointed replacements. The city council legally confirmed the appointments. The former commissioners refused to leave.

They showed up at meetings and tried to act like commissioners. They even, comically, passed a measure saying their replacements were the interlopers.

The former members have made bogus arguments that Klipsch acted improperly – and they and commission director, Latrice Lacey, have said, amazingly, that the expiration of a term does not constitute a vacancy on the panel. And, for this, the work of the commission has been held up for a year.

Latham’s ruling, however, was clear.

"Defendants provide no sound authority to support their claim that they have some continued, unrestrained right to serve upon the expiration of their statutorily-provided two-year terms in office," he wrote. If he were to accept their reasoning, the judge added, "it would lead to lifetime appointments for DCRC commissioners. This would be an illogical result.”

Greenwalt filed an answer to the city's petition, along with a 2019 memo from Lacey, which the judge said contained "mostly irrelevant facts and arguments". (Lacey filed a motion that she be allowed to intervene in the case, which the city has resisted.)

It hardly needs repeating, but it has taken far too long to get to this point. It is time this embarrassing episode end. For a year, the ex-commissioners and their allies have obstructed the commission's work and tried to improperly seize power. There is no longer (and never was) any issue as to who rightfully sits on the commission. It is time drop this charade.


Catch the latest in Opinion

* I understand and agree that registration on or use of this site constitutes agreement to its user agreement and privacy policy.

Related to this story

Most Popular

Thumbs Up ... to the decision to remove the federal prison at Thomson, Ill., from a list of quarantine sites to monitor inmates entering the prison system for their health.

Thumbs Up ... to the state of Illinois for its $25 million grant program aimed at fast-tracking construction projects. The grants, which were announced earlier this week, will go to local governments and be between $500,000 to $5 million.

In early April, after President Trump said he intended to fire Michael Atkinson, the inspector general for the intelligence community, Sen. Chuck Grassley, R-Iowa, co-wrote a letter to the White House asking for an explanation.

Get up-to-the-minute news sent straight to your device.


News Alerts

Breaking News