Skip to main content
You have permission to edit this article.
Edit
The many benefits immigrants bring to the US

The many benefits immigrants bring to the US

  • Comments
{{featured_button_text}}

Recent debates over America’s immigration policy are exposing a deep rift in conservative politics. In the Utah Senate debate earlier this year, Mitt Romney referred to U.S. policies that separated immigrant parents from their children at the border as a “dark chapter” in American history. Others have urged President Donald Trump to uphold his campaign promises by taking stronger steps to restrict immigration.

Those who support restricting immigration claim that the U.S. economy is already at full employment, which means an influx of immigrants will only further strain public funds that are already stretched too thin.

While calls for restricting immigration are often made on economic grounds, there is little evidence that restricting immigration will improve America’s economic situation. If anything, restrictionism would hurt the economy.

Using phrases like “full employment” implies that the economy is a fixed pie. In reality, economies grow along with the population. More labor means more output. In turn, more immigrants mean more shoppers at local businesses, more jobs, and more prosperity for all Americans.

Still, anti-immigration advocates insist that immigrants take jobs away from native-born Americans. But research from immigration expert Dr. Giovanni Peri suggests that restricting the flow of immigrants actually slows job creation, leaving natives with fewer opportunities. On average, business owners employing immigrants have lower labor costs, which enables them to invest those savings in expanding their operations. As businesses grow, they hire more employees, leading to a net growth in jobs available.

There’s also powerful and growing evidence that immigrants start more businesses than natives. They’re twice as likely to do so, it turns out. So it’s not just that immigrants allow existing businesses to expand, they also give natives more jobs to choose from. Instead of taking employment options away from natives, immigrants are creating them.

Besides the jobs immigrants create, it’s unlikely that the U.S. economy is at full capacity. Here, too, studies show that rather than straining labor markets by moving to areas with few available jobs, immigrants tend to enter areas that have existing labor market gaps. In fact, because of immigration restrictions, some jobs go unfilled for long periods of time.

Immigration expert Dr. Michael Clemens conducted one study that looked at the North Carolina Growers Association. The NCGA is a group of farmers who collectively apply for work visas to staff their farms. In 2011, the NCGA needed 6,500 workers, yet only around 260 natives applied — just 4 percent of the NCGA’s total needs. Dr. Clemens’ study concludes that “foreign agriculture workers fill jobs that native workers will not, and that by filling these jobs, foreign workers benefit North Carolina’s economy and create jobs for Americans.”

Critics of increased immigration can tout the costs of immigration, but they also can’t ignore its benefits. Immigrants are highly motivated contributors to the American economy, not deadweight living on public resources.

Immigration will be a defining element of President Trump’s legacy. Reducing immigration restrictions by removing quotas that keep highly educated immigrants out of the United States and protecting the children of undocumented immigrants are two points where President Trump can ensure that his record on immigration is a positive one.

Critics of increased immigration can tout the costs of immigration, but they also can’t ignore its benefits.

Josh T. Smith is a research manager at the Center for Growth and Opportunity at Utah State University and a contributor with Young Voices. Jesse Baker is a CGO graduate research fellow at the Center for Growth and Opportunity.

Critics of increased immigration can tout the costs of immigration, but they also can’t ignore its benefits. Immigrants are highly motivated contributors to the American economy, not deadweight living on public resources.

pull quote
0
2
0
0
3

Catch the latest in Opinion

* I understand and agree that registration on or use of this site constitutes agreement to its user agreement and privacy policy.

Related to this story

Most Popular

Recently, one of United Way’s funded agencies invited me to hear from "Jeremy," a 17-year-old young man who was an accessory to a car theft that led to a more serious crime. This local nonprofit is providing Jeremy an opportunity to turn his life around by practicing critical life, social and job skills. While listening to his story, it was clear to me that his most impressionable years were sacrificed partly because he wasn’t exposed to a different path. How many teens like Jeremy are lost in their own surroundings, unaware that they have the power to change their own course?

  • Updated

A narrow majority of Rock Island aldermen voted last week to trim bar closing times. Now, instead of shutting the doors at 3 a.m., bars will have to close an hour earlier.

Like many who have been locked down at home this past year, I’ve been passing the time by binge-watching TV, mainly foreign series. Among the best of these is the "Deutschland" series, about East German spies in the latter days of the Cold War, much of it based on real events.

Get up-to-the-minute news sent straight to your device.

Topics

News Alerts

Breaking News