Editorial: Good pick, bad process


Share
Posted Online: Dec. 02, 2012, 6:00 am
Comment on this story | Print this story | Email this story
The Dispatch and The Rock Island Argus
There really wasn't anything all that unusual in the Black Hawk College Board decision last week to call closed sessions to talk about how to tab a new member for that elected body.

And that is, perhaps, the most troublesome thing about it.

It is the all-too common inclination of some public bodies here in the Quad-Cities and elsewhere in Illinois to do more of the public's business behind closed doors than they should. Panels governing schools may, however, be the most consistent offenders.

Not that we are criticizing Black Hawk College trustees' decision Thursday to tab Larry Lorensen to replace former trustee Sonia Berg, whose resignation took effect Nov. 15. The opposite, in fact. Few know the college better than the former Moline mayor who has taught there for 35 years and has served on one of the school's foundations. His temporary appointment runs through the April 2013 election, which could give voters the chance to choose the person to fill the spot.

But this wise choice does not make the process by which it was made any more palatable. Rather than justify holding two closed sessions to arrive at this smart pick, the result of the behind-closed doors selection highlights just how unnecessary it was to do it secretly.

Indeed, we continue to believe using closed sessions to discuss the timing and the process of selection clearly violated the state's Open Meeting Act. So does Don Craven, the sunshine law expert who serves as attorney for the Illinois Press Association.

Neither the board's belated release Wednesday of a synopsis of the closed session, nor its welcome choice of Mr. Lorensen after another closed session on Thursday negates the concerns raised here.

Why should you care that trustees didn't appear to trust you with such critical details?

Let's start with the huge responsibility members of boards like this one carry for you; not just for your tax dollars -- though they are certainly significant -- but in guiding a vast segment of our population's future. Shouldn't taxpayers know what kind of person the trustees are looking for to help them in that quest?

What about diversity of opinion? Was the board seeking someone who would rubber stamp decisions of veteran trustees and college staff? Perhaps trustees were doing exactly the opposite. The public has a right to know. So do potential candidates who might be interested in running in April to fill the spot. Doesn't it seem likely that the voters would have a far larger pool of good candidates from which to choose if the board offered the public an idea of what kind of board member the panel is looking for?

Indeed, we can't image a good reason for NOT publicly debating such weighty matters.

If Illinoisans had wanted elites to run their grade, high school and community college boards, they wouldn't have made the offices elected ones. We'd let those who believe they know better than the rest of us make such choices. If a board can decide in secret the details for finding a new board member, doesn't it amount to the same thing?

Such secrecy also does little for a board's credibility. If trustees go into closed session to discuss something as seemingly innocuous as what kind of characteristics they'd like to see in a board member whom, we presume, must eventually stand for election, what else might they be discussing away from the public's prying eyes?

We're not suggesting that Black Hawk College trustees were up to no good. Indeed, we have the utmost respect and gratitude for these hardworking public servants who choose to take on such tough, unpaid jobs that put them in the public eye.

Nor are we saying that they don't have the best interests of their constituents at heart. Indeed, the board's choices here seemed to prove that they do.
And that's why we find it so troubling when public bodies so easily choose to close the public out of key decision making processes.

Indeed, little good can come of fostering a culture of secrecy-first. So, why do it?















 



Local events heading








  Today is Wednesday, April 23, the 113th day of 2014. There are 252 days left in the year.

1864 — 150 years ago: Some persons are negotiating for 80 feet of ground on Illinois Street with a view of erecting four stores thereon. It would serve a better purpose if the money was invested in neat tenement houses.
1889 — 125 years ago: The Central station, car house and stables of the Moline-Rock Island Horse Railway line of the Holmes syndicate, together with 15 cars and 42 head of horses, were destroyed by fire. The loss was at $15,000.
1914 — 100 years ago: Vera Cruz, Mexico, after a day and night of resistance to American forces, gradually ceased opposition. The American forces took complete control of the city.
1939 — 75 years ago: Dr. R. Bruce Collins was reelected for a second term as president of the Lower Rock Island County Tuberculosis Association.
1964 — 50 years ago: Work is scheduled to begin this summer on construction of a new men's residence complex and an addition to the dining facilities at Westerlin Hall at Augustana College.
1989 — 25 years ago: Special Olympics competitors were triple winners at Rock Island High School Saturday. The participants vanquished the rain that fell during the competition, and some won their events; but most important, they triumphed over their own disabilities.




(More History)